Austin Downtown Arts Magazine
Dance
Butoh -- Dance of Darkness?
by Christopher Keimling
The performers exhibit a variety of symptoms. Ghostly white
make-up covers their faces. Their heads are bald, or wild
with untamed hair. Their limbs move in slow motion, sometimes
seeming as if they are pulled by invisible strings. Their
faces are blank, or contorted with expressions that seem to
indicate of sadness, anguish, or insanity. Their eyes are
unfocused -- or focused inward -- on regions most of us are
reluctant to explore.
This is Butoh, an underground dance form that emerged in
Japan in the 1960s.
It is not for the weak.
"It mirrors the situation the modern human is in,"
said Margita Pencevova-Paskvleva. Pencevova-Paskvleva lives
in Artplex, a building at 17th and Guadalupe, within the uptown
cultural district, where artists work and live. She is a costume
designer, an artist and a Butoh enthusiast. When describing
Butoh (pronounced BOO-toe) she grows animated and makes references
to Carl Jung.
"The only way you can grow as an individual is through
pain. Only by facing it, acknowledging it, and embracing it
can we move on with our lives," she said. "Instead
of accepting pain as a part of life, however, most people
in Western society seek merely to block it out. They fear
pain. They hope it will just go away with the help of Prozac
or some other drug."
Butoh doesn't shirk from exploring unpleasant human feelings,
which probably explains why it can be so disturbing to watch.
"People react in different ways," Pencevova-Paskvleva
said. "They get angry, or they're so moved they weep.
Some walk out, calling [the dancers] freaks." Interestingly
enough, she's seen children react differently: they wave at
the dancers, or imitate them, she says.
Back to Top
However audiences react to Butoh, one thing is certain --
they will react. Pencevova-Paskvleva witnessed some powerful
reactions first-hand when she invited her Butoh mentor Doranne
Crable to perform at Artplex. A professor of Performance Studies
at Evergreen State College in Olympia, Washington, Crable
has studied and performed Butoh for 20 years. She has studied
with Kazuo Ohno, who, along with the late Tatsumi Hijikata,
is a founding father of this unique modern dance form.
Crable performed in the ACA gallery located on the ground
floor of Artplex. Her July 24th appearance was part of the
opening reception for an exhibition of works by the tenants
of Artplex entitled Open Doors. Coming out in a black slip
and a kimono, she danced through the gallery and through the
standing crowd to the sound of four boomboxes simultaneously
playing different music. Not separated from her surroundings,
she improvised, reacting to the paintings around her and at
one point mounting a pedestal, where she danced an image called
"old dog," in which her legs began trembling. A
woman in the audience was so moved by this that she reached
out a hand to help Crable down, and Crable reacted by drawing
an invisible string in the air between their two hearts. For
Crable and others, it was one of the more memorable moments
of the evening's performance.
When I spoke with Doranne Crable, I found her to be a very
spiritual person who feels very much in harmony with nature.
She sees Butoh as a healing force.
"Flamenco is fiery and sensual, ballet is ethereal and
ephemeral, and modern dance displays the beauty and power
of the human body. But Butoh creates and addresses a kind
of beauty that can't be defined," she says.
To Crable, Butoh involves "stripping away the protective
masks that humans wear as performers" in order to come
into the "vulnerable and gentle part of the human heart."
That said, what exactly is Butoh? I find that it's easier
to define what Butoh isn't. Butoh isn't mime. (Don't let the
white face paint fool you.) Although many dancers are often
involved, performances don't have linear story lines like
plays or operas. Butoh also isn't about being pretty or showing
off tricky dance manuevers. Rather than trying to impress
an audience, Butoh attempts to express the human condition.
"Butoh is grounded in the earth. Rather than leaping
off of it, I dance into it," Crable says. She explained
the sensation she feels when she dances: "Sometimes it's
as if my feet are magnetized and I'm walking on a metal surface,
and other times it feels as if I can walk on lily pads."
Her eyes, like those of all Butoh dancers, seem distant and
unfocused when she performs. "It's an inner focus. It's
like looking through curtains of rain. I look at space instead
of objects in space." She tries to keep her facial features
devoid of emotion so as to not impose emotions on the audience.
"Instead of making them feel, I let them feel,"
she says.
To refer to different motions, and as an aid to her dancing,
Crable borrows images from nature (such as a heron or a rose)
and translates them into movement. Expressed in dance form,
these images provoke emotional responses based on the viewer's
own experiences. When she dances an "old dog" for
example, her goal is not literal imitation. Rather, her motions
symbolize something larger, such as frailty or infirmity in
general. On a personal level, her body movements might trigger
an emotional memory. Watching her dance an "old dog"
might make you think of your grandfather who passed away,
for example.
Before speaking with Doranne Crable, my own experience with
Butoh had been limited to a lurid video entitled Butoh --
Dance of Darkness. This documentary featured some ghastly
images that made me feel as if I had been granted a special
glimpse of damned souls in a Japanese vision of hell.
Back to Top
Many scenes featured partial nudity. In others, the dancers
donned pieces of industrial junk, as with two men whose torsos
were wrapped in vacuum cleaner hoses. Fire was also incorporated
into some performances, but these props didn't draw attention
away from what was truly disturbing -- the dancers themselves.
Some stuck out their tongues and drooled, while others rolled
their eyes back into their heads. Their expressions were those
of demons, zombies or village idiots. I had a hard time reconciling
some of these images with Doranne Crable's kinder and gentler
brand of Butoh, until I learned more about the movement.
Butoh was born in a turbulent time, when Japan was struggling
with its cultural identity. In the aftermath of World War
II, Japan became an increasingly modernized, urbanized, and
thus westernized society. This didn't sit well with many people,
and this sense of unease had a profound influence on Butoh.
In its beginnings, Butoh was in large part an act of rebellion.
It was a rejection of "progress" and a rejection
of Western ideals of beauty. Tired of seeing ballet dancers
skipping around in tutus, Botuh performers offered something
new, shocking, and without rules -- an avant-garde dance form
that nevertheless was distinctly Japanese.
Butoh also explored the dark side of human nature. There
is a definite river of darkness that runs through Botuh, and
if you swim upstream, you will find Hijikata at the source.
Themes of death and the grotesque were introduced by Hijikata,
as well as by the horrors of Nagasaki and Hiroshima.
For Crable and other Botuh artists, however, Botuh's ultimate
purpose is not to shock, but rather to heal. Crable enjoys
teaching Butoh, despite the risk that some of her students
might run off and form inferior Butoh troupes without fully
understanding and respecting the dance. Since its beginnings,
Botuh has gained a more international presence. There is a
danger that popularity could cheapen and endanger the art
of Butoh. As a commentor in the Dance of Darkness film puts
it: "A large part of Butoh is exotic spectacle, but if
it translates no further than exotic spectacle, then it will
be dead." As for myself, I think it's only a matter of
time before an MTV artist like Marilyn Manson incorporates
Butoh dancers in a music video. While I admit this would be
interesting, it wouldn't do justice to the form. It should
be experienced in its proper setting, and with a proper appreciation
of its power.
"I try to create a moment suspended in time," Doranne
Crable said. My interview with Crable gave me a renewed appreciation
of the momentary nature of life. One of her favorite quotes
is as follows:
"We are born in a flash of light, then evening comes
and it is dark forever."
Back to Top
|